Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Stories Untold, Lost or Insubstantial




In my quest for new stories, I’ve heard a number that, ultimately, I wasn’t given permission to publish.  In one case, the woman was too anguished over long-ago events to want to go public.  (Nor am I sure that telling me her story helped her.  Some memories, no doubt, are better left uncovered.)  In another case, a blithe spirit recounted a lively tale of her younger days, and then, upon reflection, opted for discretion. 
Then there are the lost stories.  Recently, a friend who was raised Catholic but has not remained in the Church told me that she has no recollection of birth control being an issue for her parents or aunts or uncles, that the entire Catholic experience felt remote.  I think it important to collect and share what family stories we can because those narratives contribute to wisdom and truth.  The “Greatest Generation” has mostly departed this earth, leaving stories in the memories of their survivors, stories with “sell-by” dates.  I will continue to search these stories out.
Then there are the stories that aren’t.  Often when I talk with Catholic adults of child-bearing years I’m surprised at how unaware they are of the Church’s teaching on sexual morality.  Both cradle Catholics and converts, for instance, seem to feel free to choose among all types of birth control, the exception being the women writing for blogs that espouse NFP, not people I see in person.  The young adult Catholics I see in person are actively seeking spirituality, community and ethical living for themselves and their children.  Their religious journey appears to me remarkably free of what some might term “baggage.”



Another Comment Gratefully Received!

Thanks, Pat, for your comment and thanks for reading all of the posts.  Please consider contributing more of your own story.

It is interesting to see all sides of this topic from firsthand accounts. I read all of the posts and can find myself in many of them. I used birth control without guilt. I stopped using them when the side effects issues finally convinced me it was not healthy. I have five children and no regrets. Hugs, GraceinAZ (Pat)

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

A Comment Belatedly Posted

This comment was made several weeks ago in response to the  post "Two Old Stories."  (I'm still catching on about opening and posting comments.)

"Women of all religions, and poor women for the most part, were treated with disdain by religious leaders, doctors, etc....

"My mother, Jewish, was allowed to be in labor for days...when my father was asked: Who do you want us to save--the baby or your wife? My sister, Penelope, choked by the umbilical cord, was born dead. My mother survived to have 3 children. My father who asked in response to the doctors' question: Can't you save both? was forever mistrusted by my mother's sister as a result.

"My mother was in the same generation of women who wrote about their experiences above. Similar attitudes towards women condemning them to a less than heavenly life here on earth."

The Seventh Child



I’m not sure of the propriety of quoting other people’s published stories.  I was going to paraphrase the first few paragraphs of “From Maine to Thailand,” the memoir of Roger Parent that appears in the Number 87 volume of Echoes, but it’s written so well and so succinctly that I’m going to post it as is and hope that I’m not committing any sort of violation.
“My parents had six children and could not afford another child.  Maybe they didn’t want another child, but I don’t know that.  It was near the end of the Depression.  They had lost their savings, jobs were scarce, and birth control was an inexact science fraught with moral implications for my parents who were devout Catholics.  They tried to follow the birth control allowed by the Church: abstinence, nursing the last baby as long as possible, and having sexual intercourse only when they thought my mother was not fertile.  But nothing worked and I was born January 22, 1939, on a very cold day in Lille, a small village in northern Maine, a few hundred yards from the border with New Brunswick, Canada.
“After I was born, my parents, although not naturally superstitious, tried the birth control of an old French Acadian tale: if you named the seventh child after the grandfathers or grandmothers, this would be your last child.  I was the seventh child, and my parents, desperate not to have another, named me Jean Octave Roger.
“Unfortunately for my parents, and fortunately for my three younger sisters, this birth control didn’t work.  Years later, toward the end of her long life, my mother told me, ‘If I were young, I would not follow the Church’s ban on artificial [whatever that means] birth control.’”

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Whatever Made Me Think I Had Choices?



I recently found on my bookshelf a Catholic Update from 1983 titled “Fifteen Years After Humanae Vitae: Birth Control and the Conscientious Catholic.”  This four-page, monthly paper is published by St. Anthony Messenger Press, not exactly a bastion of liberalism.   And, yet, it concludes by asking couples to make up their own minds on the topic, to follow their consciences.     
Kenneth Overberg, SJ, begins the article by conjecturing that many will say it’s unnecessary, the polar positions being that Humanae Vitae is the final word which  must be followed no matter what and that it’s nonsense.  The aim of this Update is to help those in the middle deal conscientiously with the matter.
This Update would have come into my home about the time my husband and I were attending NFP workshops.  At that time my bookshelf contained a copy of Humane Vitae, a weighty book with a bright yellow dustcover, but I don’t think I ever got around to reading much of it.  This Update, however, looks well read.  
The author writes first about papal teachings in general.  Even infallible statements, such as Humanae Vitae, should be respected as guides to Christian living.   In Humanae Vitae Pope Paul praises human dignity, the meaningfulness of sexuality and the responsibility entailed in parenthood.  What stirred controversy, however, is the complete prohibition of contraception as an "intrinsic evil."  The unitive and procreative aspects of sex must not be separated.  Every act of sexual intercourse must be open to conception.  NFP is acceptable because it takes passive advantage of a woman’s natural cycle of fertility without involving a positive act against conception.
Pope John Paul II in Familiaris Consortio reaffirms Humanae Vitae’s stance against artificial birth control, which prevents the complete self-giving of husband and wife.  NFP, on the other hand, encourages dialogue, respect, shared responsibility and self-control.
National conferences of bishops demonstrated a range of reactions to the papal teachings of Paul and John Paul regarding birth control.  Both the German and the Scandinavian bishops stressed placing one’s conscience above following an encyclical that does not convince.  They added that no such dissenter should be considered a “bad Catholic.” The Canadian bishops issued a statement in which they stressed “a spirit of openness to the teaching of the Church” but also the assurance that “whoever honestly chooses the course which seems right to him does so in good conscience.”  After the Canadian bishops presented Pope Paul VI with a copy of their statement, they heard back from their apostolic delegate that the Pope was “quite satisfied with their interpretation.”  In Human Life in Our Day, on the other hand, the American bishops reiterated Paul’s language, calling contraception an “objective evil.” 
US theologians did not necessarily agree with the US bishops.  Richard McCormick, SJ, criticized Humanae Vitae for making biology and natural processes the basis for morality when the criterion should be the whole person, not one aspect only.  Many contemporary theologians agreed with McCormick.  To them, the papal documents looked outmoded.
The Update goes on to explain the workings of conscience.  The author calls conscience the self asking, “What ought I to do?” and “What ought I to be?”  The first dimension of conscience is general moral awareness—knowing right from wrong.  The second is the search for specific moral values—the search for truth.  The third is concrete judgment—faced with conflicting moral values and in the light of the search for truth, making a choice. 
It seems to me that the mature, conscious consideration and decision making that this article advocates would turn us all into "Cafeteria Catholics."  Given the rich and varied fare of the Catholic spread, in the end we must make choices.  Not to do so would render us either starving or stuffed and sick. 
When we were teenagers, the brother a year older than I said, "Barbara, you're a born follower."  He may have been right.  With any novel idea, there seems to be a lag before I catch up with bolder, more original thinkers.  When, after ten years of NFP, I switched to the diaphragm it was not in the spirit of revolt.  The seeds had been sown by the views I’d been exposed to in my reading and in the zeitgeist—not just outside the Church but inside as well.
After three natural childbirths and three breastfed babies, the natural and holistic method of NFP had fit right in.  And yet, although I deplore the high rate of C-sections, I would have wanted to have one if the life of me or my baby depended on it.  I would have bottle fed a baby if he failed to thrive on my milk.  I would have accepted painkillers if natural techniques failed.  And so when during menopause NFP became so very chancy I turned to a surer, artificial method.

Feeling Trapped in NFP



I've found a couple of other blogs by Catholic mothers of young children.  Like Conversion Diary, these blogs are written by Moms who practice only NFP to space children or avoid conception altogether.  Most of the posts and comments on the topic of NFP are upbeat.  In one comment, however, a young woman complains bitterly.  She writes that she was raised by parents who practiced NFP and that her mother was a fanatic on the subject.  The young woman herself has stayed the course but fears it's ruining her marriage.  She thinks that her Protestant friends who use artificial contraception have happier marriages.  NFP permits sex at the time of the month when she's least interested in it and prohibits it when she's most interested.  She's ready to quit but can't get up the nerve.

Monday, December 17, 2012

A Tale of Three Sisters

Once upon a time a long time ago there were three sisters close in age who married young.  Over the next dozen years, each had a half dozen or so children.  Each sister loved her children and loved being a mother but eventually wanted the babies to stop coming.  Each talked things over with her husband.  Two went on to consult their doctors and compassionate priests.  These two went on the Pill, had no more pregnancies and lived happily ever after.



The third sister had no more pregnancies either.  She did not consult a doctor or a priest on the matter because her husband was one hundred percent against artificial birth control.  Over the next few years, onlookers noticed a rift widening between the couple that did not lessen even as the husband became ill and died a premature death.  It took the grieving widow several years to come to terms with the suffering she and her husband had undergone as a result of their inability to find common ground, and during that time she stayed away from church.  Eventually, she regained her naturally buoyant spirit, returned to the sacraments and went on to live happily ever after.